CONSTRUCTIVE RUINS

HOW LIMBO ACCRA SEIZES OPPORTUNITY IN UNFINISHED STRUCTURES AROUND THE GLOBE

by Angel Harvey-Ideozu

Emil Grip (left) and Dominique Petit-Frère (right), co-founders of Limbo Accra, pose outside Tracey Towers, the tallest building in the Bronx. Designed by architect Paul Rudolph and opened to the public in 1974, the mega-structure appears like two futuristic concrete obelisks, a style that suits the Afro-futurist bent of Limbo Accra’s practice. Styling by Kusi Kubi. Portrait by Caroline Tompkins for PIN–UP.

Standing tall and ghostly on the bank of the Labadi Township in Accra, Ghana, is La Beach Towers, a residential development that came to a screeching halt in 2016 amid a flurry of rumors questioning its structural and financial integrity. All concrete floors and jutting rods, it is, according to Limbo Accra — the spatial design studio run by the couple Dominique Petit-Frère and Emil Grip — the city’s “very own equivalent to the Empire State Building in New York City.” The comparison is just as ironic and brilliant as the “BLACK EXCELLENCE” graffiti on the wall separating the 17-story failed plot from the shores of the South Atlantic Ocean. Limbo Accra’s practice focuses on these seemingly failed, incomplete, and dismissed sites like La Beach Towers, which fleck the African continent and make up a third of Ghana’s entire built environment. Petit-Frère and Grip regard them as, “one of the most significant architectural typologies in Africa,” and work to witness, document, and “activate” them through physical exhibitions and virtual renderings that create new, speculative narratives for the structures. As Petit-Frère and Grip have begun to expand their practice by documenting and cataloguing these structures with Into the Voidan extensive digital (and eventually physical) archive backed by a grant from The Obel Foundation — the frozen-in-time La Beach Towers was the first artifact in their collection.

Location: Accra, Ghana
5.5593° N, 0.1974° W
Architect:
Tony Yaw Asare
Construction Start:
2011 
Construction Suspended:
2016

The La Beach Towers on Accra’s Atlantic coastline was the first digital artifact in Limbo Accra’s archive. It has become a landmark, often humorously referred to as Accra’s equivalent to New York’s Empire State Building. Construction started in 2011 for what was to become a luxury beachfront residential project. It was co-owned by a member of the Ghanaian Parliament, J. B. Danquah-Adu, who was murdered in 2016, leading to an abrupt end of construction and leaving the 17-story structure unfinished and succumbing to decay from salt air corrosion. Locals are now debating whether the building should be demolished or converted into a factory or warehouse, providing jobs for nearby communities.

Founded in Ghana’s capital city in 2018, Limbo Accra’s name is a play on its relationship to the liminal — Limbo — and its place of origin — Accra. The duo had originally moved back to the land of Petit-Frère’s mother’s family to conduct research for their respective graduate and undergraduate theses. And it was there, in the wake of the modernization efforts that have rocked many countries of the so-called Global South, that Petit-Frère and Grip took notice of the state of Ghana’s built (or, perhaps more accurately, unbuilt) environment. “We realized that half of the city was more or less unfinished,” Petit-Frère says. “You have this amazing place full of so much creative energy, potential, and opportunity without the actual space to accommodate that.”

With a shared “curiosity for the built environment and the future of our surroundings,” Petit-Frère and Grip have endeavored to reframe this unfinished architecture through site-specific interventions, installations, and exhibitions: “a collective re-imaginative effort into seeing what these spaces can be utilized as,” Grip says. Their 2018 activation of a semi-finished mansion in Adjiringanor, an affluent neighborhood in Accra, where they staged an exhibition of works by nine local artists, was the studio’s first project, but many more collaborative efforts have followed. In 2021, they designed their first built project: the community-led Freedom Skatepark, which Virgil Abloh helped to fund. Last year, the pair participated in the second edition of the Sharjah Architecture Triennial with SUPER LIMBO, an installation of interlaced and occasionally tied and knotted swags of calico cotton fabric designed and installed in collaboration with artist and architectural designer Anne-Lise Agossa and Super Yaya designer Rym Beydoun.

Location: Sharjah, United Arab Emirates
25.331231° N, 55.362706° E
Architect:
Darwish Engineering
Construction Start:
2008
Construction Suspended:
N/A

Location: Lagos, Nigeria
6.5244° N, 3.3792° E
Architect:
N/A
Construction Start:
1982
Construction Suspended:
1992

This 18-story government building for the Nigeria Social Insurance Trust Fund in Lagos has stood unfinished for over thirty years. It was built to ease congestion on Lagos Island during the military regime of Ibrahim Babangida in the 1980s, who shifted government agencies to this more Eastern area of the country’s former capital, Lagos. After the government’s 1991 relocation to Abuja, in central Nigeria, many of these projects were abandoned, leaving nearly completed structures such as this one in limbo. Given its location, experts still estimate the building’s worth at 50 billion Nigerian Naira (approximately 38 million American dollars). While the authorities cannot decide what to do with it, locals have used Ile Nla (“massive house”) for their means: squatters have moved in, auto-mechanic workshops have set up shop there, and young boys hang out and use it as a football pitch.

Location: Sharjah, United Arab Emirates
25.3562° N, 55.4272° E
Architect: N/A
Construction Start: N/A
Construction Suspended: N/A

In the UAE, unfinished building projects abound despite the country’s wealth. These structures, abandoned or incomplete due to funding shortages or regulatory issues, are reminders of rapidly developing nations’ challenges. Pictured here is the carcass of a commercial real estate project in Sharjah’s Al Nud neighborhood that has been left untouched for over 15 years. The contrast between these incomplete projects and Sharjah’s otherwise polished skyline of skyscrapers highlights the complexities of progress. It’s not the only abandoned Sharjah building Limbo Accra has cast their sight on: they presented an installation of woven calico cotton (in collaboration with Super Yaya designer Rym Beydoun and architect Anne-Lise Agoosa) during the 2023 Sharjah Architecture Triennial, located in an unfinished, 700,000 square foot Sharjah Mall.

There is a unique sensitivity in Limbo’s approach, which is especially perceptible in their use of language. While one could easily see such unfinished, ambitious, concrete structures as brutal, under the watchful and tolerant eye of Petit-Frère and Grip, they become “unsure,” “unaware,” “hesitant and purposeless,” and “trapped.” Limbo Accra innately seeks to redefine by repositioning — not the structure or its state, but the viewer and their perception of it. It is this perspective that transforms caretakers of incomplete buildings and tracts into “stewards of the land.”

This modus of reframing of preconceived narratives is apparent in Limbo’s respect for African oral traditions, which many diminish as an impediment to the continent’s development and facilitating its cultural erasure, as well as their consideration for biodiversity. Nature is typically disposed of in Ghanaian development projects, with sites notoriously wiped clean before the start of any construction project — “Has the land been cleared?” is a common refrain heard among speculators. Limbo, however, embraces local ecosystems, seeing beauty in the opportunity that the state of incompletion provides for the natural world to take over.

After spending the last half-decade drawing awareness to these incomplete structures, Petit-Frère and Grip now want to resurrect them from Limbo in a Dantean sense — the First Circle of the Inferno, the borderland, the Limbo of the Unbaptized — as they bring forth Into the Void. Using the idea of an open-sourced, communal history as the basis for their digital archive, Limbo Accra looks to sites like Twitter, Reddit, and even YouTube to showcase the work of “everyday Africans [who] are already taking their cameras, going to these sites, and documenting them,” as Petit-Frère says. In the Limbo way, everyday people become authors in the studio’s practice. Petit-Frère and Grip scan these communally sourced photographs and use photogrammetry to reconstruct the world in a “skeletal-carcass” form. They use crowdsourced audio recordings as background noise in their videos, and embrace the public’s ideas of what these buildings could be. In this world-building exercise marrying sound, image, and language, Limbo insists on the value the pre-existing — a total subversion of much of the contemporary impulses of modern architecture and material culture at large, which is concerned with, if not infatuated by, the idea of making — the more, the new, the total, and as a result, the labeled, the certain, the fixed.

Location: Mindelo, São Vicente, Cabo Verde
16.8765° N, 24.9813° W
Architect: N/A
Construction Start: 2013
Construction Suspended: 2018

In 2013, a public square was sold by the local municipality of Mindelo to developers to build a mall. The sale was controversial and much protested by locals, who accused the city’s mayor of a lack of transparency in approving private investment projects and destroying Cabo Verde’s architectural heritage. The square had been lovingly nicknamed Pracinha Dos Namorados (“The Lovers’ Square”), a spot of many first kisses. Construction of the mall ended abruptly in 2017, leaving the site in limbo ever since. Locals now refer to it as The Titanic, as it resembles a stranded boat on the shores of São Vicente island.

Location: Touba, Senegal
14.8666° N, 15.8995° W
Architect:
N/A
Construction Start:
1981
Construction Suspended:
1984

This unfinished five-story palace-like structure was built in the early 1980s on the outskirts of the Senegalese city of Touba. It was commissioned by El Hadji Ndiouga Kébé (1914–84), a Senegalese businessman who intended it as both his private residence as well as a tribute to Sufi saint and religious leader Cheikh Ahmadou Bamba (1853–1927), founder of the city of Touba. (The concrete arches are said to be inspired by the architecture of the great mosque of Djenné, in neighboring Mali.) Since Kébé died in 1984, the modern ruin has been left nearly untouched, with locals lending an almost mythical power to this ornate concrete skeleton. Limbo Accra attributes “immense historical and cultural significance” to this “incomplete architectural wonder” as “an unintentional texture of memory left as a void.”

Digital Design by Thomas McLucas. Courtesy of Limbo Accra.

Petit-Frère and Grip hope this living archive will encourage people to further engage these sites and imagine what they could be. After all, the pair have often emphasized the importance to their practice of the idea of Afro-utopia: the grand African future marked by “prosperity, opportunity, inspiration, and hope.” Limbo’s otherworld, as they imagine it, concrete and unfinished, occupied and ‘activated,’ is uncanny: the future come to a halt. It’s the end-of-this-world, beginning-of-another-type romance, one filled with a sense of radical optimism amongst the concrete; a copper-colored spill leaking the metallic future of a dream.